The 1 AM (06 UTC) runs of the models are available this morning and each model is consistent with its own previous run. The NAM is warmer and has less QPF (0.28 inches water), falling mostly as rain, changing to wet snow about 5-6 PM, ending about 10PM. Total snow is about 1 inch in PHL but increases to 3 inches in areas west and northwest. (Chester counties, Upper Montco).
The GFS and FV3-GFS are colder and have a higher QPF of 0.48 inches water. The GFS has snow starting earlier, then a mix of rain and snow, then more snow, ending about 11 PM. Total snowfall about 2.5 inches in northwest Philadelphia increasing to 4–5 inches the further west you go.
Both models have lower accumulations in Center City, closer to the Delaware and east into NJ.
The GFS has precipitation starting as early as late morning, instead of mid-afternoon (NAM).
It’s unusual to have such a wide range in QPF and the predicted temperature profiles from the surface to 18,000 feet are unusual in that it’s very cold aloft (supporting snow) but the models, especially the NAM, have a layer of warmer air below 5000 feet that will affect the precipitation type. The GFS is colder below 5000 feet, and as a result, is predicting more snow.
I’m still inclined to go with the GFS, but honestly, I’m not sure. This is one of those situations where sometimes knowing the possibilities is the best you can do.